Thursday 31 May 2012

POLAND / HISTORY: Operation Vistula-- A Necessary Evil (P. Dybicz)

Ethnic Ukrainians being deported from a village in SE Poland during Operation Vistula
Background: Operation Vistula (Polish: Akcja Wisła)  was carried out by Poland's Communist government between April and July 1947 in the south-eastern corner of modern-day Poland. The objectives were twofold: the military supression of the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA) and the deportation of ethnic Ukrainian civilians, as well as the related Boyko and Lemko ethnic groups, to resettlement in areas of northern and western Poland which had previously belonged to Germany.

Some argue that the operation was an unfortunate but necessary measure to prevent further inter-communal violence in the Polish-Ukrainian borderlands. It can also be seen as a response to the various massacres of Polish citizens carried out by the UPA during the war. Others argue that Operation Vistula was a shameful act of collective punishment and ethnic cleansing carried out by a totalitarian regime. The following article makes the former argument, whilst a second article to be translated and posted some time soon(ish) makes the latter argument from the point of view of an eyewitness who was deported as a child.

************************************************************************************

Although 65 years have now passed since Operation Vistula, it does not provoke any less discussion and controversy than it did in the past. One could even say that it creates more debate now than when it was carried out...



Polish civilians murdered by Ukrainian nationalists in the Volhynia region.

 In mid-1944, partisan bands of the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA) started to murder Poles in the south-east of modern-day Poland. The campaign was based on the earlier massacres in Volhynia. The UPA were implementing a directive issued by the Organisation of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN) who wished to 'cleanse' western Ukraine of Poles. The UPA and OUN did not accept the post-war borders, agreed by the 'Big Three' at Teheran, Yalta and Potsdam. Ukrainian nationalists wanted the region of Eastern Galicia, located on the Polish side of the new border, and so they set up their own underground state in the region-- Zakierzoński Country. At this time, the UPA were engaged in combat with soldiers from the USSR's 1st Polish Army as well as units of the Armia Krajowa (AK) (Polish resistance-CK) and National Armed Forces (NSZ) (Right-wing Polish paramilitaries-CK) When the Eastern Front approached the territory of pre-war Poland and when the Polish Committee of National Liberation (PKWN) (Soviet controlled provisional government-CK)  signed an agreement with the Ukrainian S.S.R to exchange populations (September and October 1944) the UPA units operating in Eastern Galicia / Zakierzoński changed their objectives.

The UPA now wanted to prevent the transfer of Ukrainians to the USSR. Their targets now included railway lines and stations, bridges and telephone lines, as well as villages and towns inhabited by Poles. There were also attacks on army and police posts and the offices of the resettlement commission. The UPA employed a scorched earth policy. Villages which had been vacated by deported Ukrainians, Lemkos and Boykos were burnt to the ground so that they could not be inhabited by Poles arriving from the USSR side of the border.

Obviously, the Polish authorities could not allow the continued existence of Ukrainian partisan units. The decision to carry out Operation Vistula was taken by the Political Bureau of the Polish Worker's Party (PPR). The direct trigger for the operation was the death of General Karol Świerczewski in an ambush at Baligród on March 28th 1947. Although the operation began on 28th April 1947 the plan had been created beforehand under the direction of General Stefan Mossor, a soldier in Piłsudski's legions, one of the planners of Poland's war against Germany and the post-war vice chief of staff (1946-1947). Mossor was also in charge of the unit which would carry out the operation. The aims were twofold: resettlement of civilians and the liquidation of UPA units. Both objectives were interconnected, as the UPA enjoyed the support of a large proportion of the Ukrainian population who aided and supplied the partisans.

A map of operation Vistula. Yellow shows areas of Ukrainian settlement before deportation and light blue indicates areas of resettlement.

Operation Vistula was also motivated by international factors. Firstly, the victorious 'Big Three' recognised the transfer of populations as helpful, and even necessary. Secondly, the Polish government could not allow the existence of hostile armed partisans, or a large number of hostile civilians who did not recognise the Polish state and had plans to create their own state, on Polish territory. Of course, Operation Vistula was not a painless action. At times it was cruel and brutal. It caused many tragedies, some of which remain unrecognised to this day. It was, however, necessary. Not only the government of the time believed this. The post-war authorities had to look at the bloody inter-communal violence and predict what would happen if they did not take any action, as well as what would happen further into the future. Even in post-Communist Poland we can find hear echoes of the Polish-Ukrainian conflict-- as with the situation in Przemyśl 5 years ago-- although thankfully they are of a much less violent strain. The rising power of nationalism in Western Ukraine should not be forgotten either.

Operation Vistula still creates controversy and various politicians have entered into the debate. In 1990 the Polish Senate condemned the action. In 2002 President Aleksander Kwaśniewski expressed regret and 5 years ago President Lech Kaczyński and Ukrainian President Victor Yuschenko condemned Operation Vistula in a joint speech and labelled it a violation of basic human rights. Yuschenko then said on 27th April that the 'perpetrator of the operation was the totalitarian Communist regime'.

These opinions do not find much support amongst many Poles, including historians. Ewa Siemaszko, co-author of a monumental work on the Volhynia massacres, argues that Operation Vistula was vital to bringing an end to the anti-Polish ideology and actions of the OUN-UPA.

Ewa Siemaszko's opinion shows that Operation Vistula cannot be viewed in isolation but has to be seen in the wider context of Polish-Ukrainian relations. The decision of the government (regardless of what one thinks of that government's legitimacy) to start the deportation of Ukrainians from the border region was widely supported at the time. Operation Vistula will no doubt contine to stir emotions fro years to come and it will continue to raise the question of whether the interests of the state are more or less important than the rights of the individual. This debate will be carried out not only by historians but also by politicians. What is the future of Polish-Ukrainian relations? Only time will tell, and they say that time is a healer...


Author: Paweł Dybicz  Taken from 'Przegłąd' magazine

56 comments:

Unknown said...

Thanks for share, Mimpi Blogger

Unknown said...

nice article
custom embroidered hats

Unknown said...

this is very nice article
embroidery digitizing

Toko Bunga Jakarta said...

nice artikel

Toko Bunga Online

Harum said...

Nice blog

Unknown said...

omg there are dead bodies here...
embroidered jackets

Unknown said...

why this is happen
monogrammed bags

Unknown said...

nice post i like it
personalized bags
embroidery services
embroidery services

obat herbal murah said...

Obat Herbal Murah

Toko Herbal Murah

Sehat dengan Herbal

Toko Herbal Murah

obat herbal murah said...

Obat Herbal Murah

Toko Herbal Murah

Sehat dengan Herbal

Toko Herbal Murah

Unknown said...

Dalam sejarah Dunia online

luka,Trik blogger pun ini bisa

karena dinilai sebagai ginseng laut”. web kuherbal Untuk Penyakit Kesehatan

Negara kita.  kunjungi website,asma baca selengkapnya dari situs ini melalui  klik disini Obat Tradisional Untuk Kanker Paru Paru Ampuh - Jika Anda memilih pengobatan kanker secara medis maka Serba serbai dunia tindakan yang dapat dilakukan adalah dengan operasi pembedahan untuk mengangkat sel kanker, Menebak siapa daku terapi radiasi, kemoterapi, dan penyuntikan Photodynamic (PTD). Selain itu, Anda juga dapat memilih pengobatan kank klik disini



Obat Untuk Kanker Otak,info selengkapnya disini kanker otak merupakan salah satu penyakit yang menyerang otak.Tumbuhan Kesehatanbaca selengkapnya dari mana dan kemana ini dia klik disini,teruskan dengan sebuah penyakit 

Daftar Harga said...

that's cool ! thanks

Berita Bola said...

Great info gan super Good Berita Bola dan Prediksi Skor Bola

Kingcuan said...

thanks


dream girl


kyosko


jis tan nu jatt james bond


the hell raiser


hindi ko kaya


david gueta titanium


ed sheeran


lie lie lie lyrics


contraluz


shamur rock your body


lil rue


vasi vasi


ass man


welcome my parade


lou reed walk on the wild side lou walk lou

Kingcuan said...

thanks

brian mcknight back at one one


ludachris


te llore un un rio mana


sad eyes enrique


rise rise


estancia estancia


single life


just like me


terazzi calvin harris calvin harris c u b a terazzi remix


enrique iglesia


prime time ham time cam meekins prime


if lose myself tonight


love don t love


border ghar kab aaoge


never had oscar isaac


ost heartstrings

Cara Kuat Berhubungan Seks said...

one million dolars thankssss :)

Unknown said...

terimakasih atas informasinya
obat tradisional asam lambung

cara membesarkan penis said...

indeed a cool website like this must, always puts a lot of satisfaction and benefit its visitors.

Obat Lemak Pada Tubuh said...

Mantepppp

morofashion.com said...

nice share bro, i like to visit your blog

____________________________________________________________________________________________
fashion wanita | fashion wanita korea | fashion wanita import | dress wanita | dress wanita import | dress wanita | dress pesta wanita | jual dress pesta wanita | gaun pesta wanita | long dress wanita | dress wanita korea | dress wanita import | dress wanita murah | dress wanita online | kemeja kerja wanita | kemeja wanita | kemeja wanita murah | kemeja wanita murah | blouse wanita | blouse wanita import | blouse wanita korea | tas wanita | tas wanita import | sandal wanita | sepatu wanita | sepatu wanita korea | sepatu wanita import | tas pria | tas ransel pria | tas selempang pria | tas laptop | tas laptop murah | tas laptop branded | tas laptop online | tas ransel laptop | tas laptop murah | tas kulit pria | tas pria branded | tas kulit pria | tas kulit branded

balidogen said...

Bali Spa
Home Balinese Traditional
Kampung Ubud
Ibunda Bungalow
Bali Wisata Murah
Bali Paket Wisata
Sewa Mobil di Bali
Bali Car Rental
Bali Car Hire
Bali Car Transport
Bali Transportation Service
Bali Car Rental
Bali Travel Online
Bali Cheap Trip
Bali Cheap Travel
Bali Tour

Printer Kartu said...

very creepy story once. I was very sad when I read the story

Printer ID Card

Qbenk Blogger said...

numpang promosi gan,, salam kenal

http://softwarelivre.org/kabarberita21/dunia-poker-dan-judi-online/sarjanapoker.com-agen-judi-poker-online-tanpa-robot
http://www.ibosocial.com/kabarberita21/pressrelease.aspx?prid=412322
http://support.advancedcustomfields.com/forums/topic/sarjanapoker-com-agen-judi-poker-online-tanpa-robot-2/
http://pusbangkol.pnri.go.id/forum_pengolahan/topik-1445-sarjanapokercom-agen-judi-poker-online-tanpa-robot.html
https://www.gcx.org/agenseo/sarjanapoker-com-agen-judi-poker-online-tanpa-robot/

Salam Sukses
http://genius.com/QbenkAttazkiyah

jarong batu black opal said...

salam kenal dan sukses
Cara Mudah Mengeluarkan Jarong Batu Black Opal dengan kertas intan
Cara Memunculkan bias api batu akik fire opal wonogiri

Bali Driver said...

Nice post, you have good writing skill
Thank you for sharing this amazing post
Visit my travel blog : Bali Driver and Bali Day Tours

jilbab syar'i murah said...

kini telah hadir jilbab instan desain untuk ,model yang lagi trendi. Dari sekian pedagang yang menjual jilbab secara online, salah satunya grosirhijabku yang mampu memberi kesan baru untuk para hijaber bisa klik disini untuk memiliki jilbab syar'i stock terbatas ,buruan miliki grosir jilbab murah online secepatnya juga. kunjungi website kami karena lebih banyak model lainnya kaya jilbab cadar, grosir gamis syar’i murah selain itu jilbab pashmina sifon motif yang bisa ahwat gunakan dengan gamis blazer

Unknown said...

When we are already one of the majors, does not mean we should be one of the future.

Obat Asam Lambung Meningkat
Rekomendasi Pengobatan Tepat Untuk Mengatasi Penyakit Maag
Pengobatan Maag
Obat Hepatitis Alami
Obat Hipertensi Tekanan Darah

Alby Lutfy said...

I was very encouraged to find this site. I wanted to thank you for this special read. I definitely savored every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
jasa fotocopy murah
batu akik

Unknown said...

When we are already one of the majors, does not mean we should be one of the future.
Modern Living Room
Living Room Decor 2015
Living Room Table Sets
Living Room Theater
Living Room Furniture

DP BBM Lucu said...

Kata Rayuan Gombal Romantis


Gambar DP BBM Rayuan Gombal Romantis


Gambar DP BBM Cinta Romantis


Gambar DP BBM Puasa Ramadhan

The New Audi Car

Undangan Pernikahan said...

Terima kasih atas waktu yang diberikan ya
Undangan Pernikahan

Undangan Pernikahan Murah

Souvenir Pernikahan

Souvenir Murah

Souvenir Pernikahan Murah Meriah

Wedding Souvenir

Wedding Souvenir Pernikahan Unik

Jual Undangan Pernikahan

Undangan Pernikahan dan Harganya

Cetak Undangan Pernikahan Murah

Harga Souvenir Pernikahan

Souvenir Pernikahan Murah Meriah

Grosir Souvenir Pernikahan

Souvenir Pernikahan Terbaru

Souvenir Ultah

Wedding Souvenir

Souvenir

Rym said...

Cara Membuat Pria Tahan Lama Dalam Bercinta

Obat Pelangsing Bokong

Khasiat Vig Power Capsule

Cara Ampuh Mengatasi Obesitas Pada Remaja

 

Obat Tradisional Herpes said...

Saya sangat berterima kasih atas kesediaan anda menyajikan informasi yang menarik dan aktual seperti ini. Terus Semangat untuk memperbaharui informasi terbaru lainnya. Salam sehat.

Cara Tradisional Mengobati Encok dan Rematik said...

terima kasih banyak karena telah bersedia menyajikan informasi yang begitu informatf seperti ini. semoga makin sukses.

Unknown said...

indeed article is very useful to everyone, thank you for the information that has been presented successfully yes obat kuat seks pria | Vig Power Capsule | obat kuat modern

Unknown said...

I am extremely impressed using your writing abilities as well as with the format on your weblog. Is that it a paid subject matter or did an individual customize it by yourself? Anyway stay up the excellent high quality writing, it is uncommon to find out a nice blog in this way one today..
2016 Toyota Avalon Review
2016 Acura ILX Premium
2016 Honda Civic Hybrid Review
2016 Mitsubishi Evolution Review

Unknown said...

Best Pool Pumps Reviews
Pentair Pool Pump
Intex Pool Pump
Hayward Pool Pump
Pool Pumps for Sale
Above Ground Pool Pumps
Solar Pool Pump
Pool Pump Timer

Best Zero Turn Mower
Best Zero Turn Mower
Zero Turn Mower Reviews
Zero Turn Mowers for Sale
Husqvarna Zero Turn Mowers
Husqvarna Zero Turn Mowers
Cheap Zero Turn Mowers
Commercial Zero Turn Mowers

Unknown said...

Best Coffee Makers
Single Cup Coffee Makers
Single Serve Coffee Makers
Bunn Coffee Makers
Mr. Coffee Coffee Makers
Espresso Coffee Makers
Commercial Coffee Makers
Stainless Steel Coffee Makers

Reclining Loveseat
Reclining Loveseat
Dual Reclining Loveseat
Recliner Loveseat
Reclining Loveseat with Console
Reclining Loveseat with Console
Reclining Loveseat with Center Console
Sectional Sofa Set
Sectional Sofas
Leather Sectional Sofa

Unknown said...

Very nice website and articles. I will be realy very pleased to visit your website. Now I am found that we actually want. I check your website everyday and attempt to learn something from a blog. Thank you and looking forward to your new submit.
2016 Ford Focus
2016 GMC Sierra
2016 Hyundai Elantra
2016 Jeep Cherokee

Unknown said...

NICE POST.
Laguku.mywapblog.com
Gudangmp3.website
Album-mp3.mywapblog.com
album-mp3.heck.in
Download mp3 Indonesia gratis

Visit my site:

=> Download lagu mp3
=> Gratis lagu mp3 terbaru
Video-Mp3.Info - gudang download video dan Mp3 gratis
=> Download lagu mp3 terbaru

Unknown said...

PRODUK PEMBESAR PENIS
PROEXTENDER
CIRI VIMAX
vakum penis
minyak pembesar penis
Viagra usa
obat klg
Vagina Termontok
Vimax asli
cIRI VIMAX ASLI
vimax asli
Alat Proextender
perangsang sex
obat kuat sex
BIKIN WANITA BERGAIRAH
obat kuat sex
pro extender
vimax herbal
Vagina artis
vimax
pro extender
obat pembesar penis
obat kuat pria
perangsang sex manjur
viagra asli
vimax asli
VIMAX ASLI
viagra
VIMAX
obat pembesar penis
vimax

Desain baju muslim said...

Great post
Menghilangkan virus di flashdisk,
Cara menghapus virus shortcut,
Software alternatif IDM,
Cara mengoptimalkan kerja firefox,
Cara menghapus adware mozilla,
Model baju pesta muslim modern,
Baju muslim sarimbit lebaran,
Desain baju renang muslim anak,
Model baju hamil muslim modern,
Model baju dress muslim modern,
Contoh usaha sampingan remaja,
Kiat sukses usaha toko online,
Usaha sampingan pasar remaja,
Usaha sampingan budidaya lele,
Peluang usaha yogurt,
Desain rumah minimalis type 54,
Desain rumah minimalis sederhana,
Rumah minimalis modern 2 lantai,
Kolam renang minimalis,
Desain atap minimalis,

Undangan Pernikahan Unik said...

Sewa kamera jogja
Sewa lensa jogja
Sewa peralatan videografi jogja
Undangan Pernikahan Unik
Sewa properti foto jogja

azaria my said...

Trimakasih atas sumber informasinya Vimax asli
Vimax
Vimax canada

kairun bandel said...

Agen Bola

Heru said...

I love it, I think it's a great step in the direction of giving Good Articles the credibility it deserves!


Indonesia Traveling
Desa Beng, Pusat Industri Baju Barong Paling Terkenal
Pantai Kusamba, Pantai Yang Tenang Di Sebelah Tenggara Bali
Pulau Serangan, Pulau Kecil Yang Menawan Di Wilayah Tenggara Pulau Bali
Kebun Raya Purwodadi
Pantai Pandawa, Objek Wisata Yang Indah di Bali
Danau Kelimutu, Danau Unik Tiga Warna di Indonesia
DANAU BUYAN DAN DANAU TAMBLINGAN, TEMPAT YANG COCOK UNTUK SEJENAK LEPAS DARI HIRUK PIKUK KOTA
Pura Rambut Siwi, Candi Dengan Panorama Yang Menawan
Pantai Kedonganan Dan Jimbaran - Tempat yang sempurna untuk Seafood Dinner
Taman Nasional Teluk Cendrawasih
Taman Botani Di Kebun Raya Bogor
Pulau Biawak, Jawa Barat - sebuah tujuan Diving dengan Keunikan Tersendiri
Tiga Tips Investasi Emas yang Perlu Anda Ketahui
Bisakah Kaya Dari Pasar Modal?
Yuk Nabung Saham

Homdec store said...

Nice Your Article
Visit Tips SEO
Belajar Google Adsense
Belajar Blogger

cream pemutih wajah aman said...

ciung wanara

cream penghilang flek said...

musim hujan bikin keki

jamkho said...

yuk order jamkho yuk

Unknown said...

Download Film Terbaru
Download Film Gratis
Film Baru
Film Kartun
Film Semi
Drama Korea
Film Bollywood
Film Thailand
Film Japan
Film Gratis
Download Movies
Film Full movie
Film Horror
Film Barat
Film Indo
Film semi terbaru
Film Terbaru
Movies

Agen Poker said...

poker galaxy
pokerterang
hitsqq

Unknown said...

hi thanks in for comment me :)

Toko Bunga Jakarta
Toko Bunga BSD

Javabetsport said...

Sabung Ayam Online
Judi Ayam Online
S128
Daftar s128
Agen Sabung Ayam Online
http://bit.ly/2Zcxj9L
http://bit.ly/2HiInIm
https://is.gd/24AmCp
https://is.gd/4shheI
https://is.gd/GbS985

Casino Online
Judi bola
Bandar judi bola
Link maxbet
Link sbo
Taruhan bola
Agen terpercaya
Judi bola online
Cara daftar Maxbet
Cara daftar S128
Cara main sabung ayam
cara daftar osg777
Cara daftar joker123

[url=http://s128.blog]Sabung Ayam Online[/url]
[url=http://s128.blog]Sabung Ayam Online[/url]
[url=http://s128.blog]Judi Ayam Online[/url]
[url=http://s128.blog]S128[/url]
[url=http://javabetsport.info]Cara daftar Maxbet[/url]
[url=http://javabetsport.info]Cara daftar S128[/url]
[url=http://javabetsport.info]Judi bola online[/url]

Angels said...

Karachi Escorts make it very easy to get Escorts in Karachi. Model details such as height, age and any other information are mentioned in the model profiles. The sexual services of Karachi escorts range from anal and deep blowjobs to BDSM. They have everything you need to make your stay unforgettable. Select the girl and call us. After accepting the terms, you can mark a superb for the girl to come to your hotel room in Karachi. Rates are negotiable and depend on the girls and the desired service.

Escorts in Karachi
Escort in Karachi
Karachi Escorts
Escorts Service in Karachi
Islamabad Escorts

Furniture Rumah Terbaru said...

good content and very usefull for me,thanks you

furniture kursi sofa
kursi syahrini terbaru
furniture kursi sofa
kursi mebel jepara
kursi mebel jepara
furniture kursi sofa
furniture kursi sofa
furniture kursi sofa