Wednesday, 29 February 2012

POLAND: Does VAT Promote A Poor Diet? (B. Tumiłowicz)



'Tell me what you pay VAT on and I will tell you which lobbyists have your government's ear.' This rule can be easily applied to Polish VAT-- the taxes added to the price of goods and services which are the main source of income for the national budget. It is especially true when it comes to VAT on foodstuffs and beverages. With food and drink there are 3 VAT bands- 5%, 8% and the full 23%. Why certain products enjoy the lower levels of taxation is a question which has caused considerable comment and suspicion because many of these products are ones which a healthy diet could really do without. VAT is 5% on corn chips and 8% on crisps, instant noodles and ketchups which include a high level of chemical substances and even some cancer-causing agents. At the same time, healthy products which are recommended by dieticians, such as mineral water, are taxed at 23%. Where is the logic?







One of the first people to notice this absurd state of affairs was PO (Platforma Obywalteska, Poland's ruling party-CK) MP John Godson (Poland's first black MP-CK)
who submitted a formal interpellation to both the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Health. Mr. Godson's knowledge and experience of food products come from his studies-- he is an engineering graduate of Nigeria's Abia State University, specialising in the fields of agriculture and agronomy. He has also worked in the laboratory of the International Institiute for Tropical Agriculture in Ibadan, Nigeria.

The effects of Mr. Godson's interpellation have been so far minimal. The health minister is still working on a reply. The finance minister has promised to take the matter into consideration but Mr. Godson has found out that the Ministry of Finance will not do anything about VAT on foodstuffs.

"I have no more ways to intervene" he explains, "The only thing I could do was to submit an interpellation, the power to legislate lies with the government. I believe that healthy food should have less VAT than unhealthy products and that the current situation is bizarre."

Unfortunately, we all know about the popularity of junk food. There have been attempts to remove fattening crisps and snacks from schools and to encourage children and teenagers to eat more apples and carrots-- both to no avail. The main factor making it difficult to change people's diets, apart from the power of advertising, is the price of junk food.

Jarma Dubiel, president of the 'Wolność i Pokój' (Freedom and Peace-CK) movement which campaigns for human rights and the environment says, "Anything which is healthy and does not increase the number of patients in hospital should be VAT free. It especially makes sense with reference to children. Short-termism prevails amongst politicians, so they cannot grasp this argument, and business beguiles them into setting favourable levels of VAT. Corruption in the decision-making process cannot be ruled out because the current VAT situation is so illogical. Children who eat crisps which contain cancer-causing agents can become addicted and this increases the chances of them requiring treatment in the future. It's high time we face a few home truths about what we eat."


********

Crisp and snack producers defend low VAT by claiming that their modern production facilities required heavy investment which has still not been repaid. Another entrepreneur from the foodstuffs sector, owner of the Konspol Group (poultry products)and vice-chairman of the Polish Chamber of Commerce, Kazimierz Pazgan is in favour of a uniform level of VAT. "We should use the tried and tested methods of the German tax system" he says, "Of course VAT is vital for the national budget but making decisions on what to produce or not based on the level of VAT for each product is incomprehensible and illogical. In whose interests are these VAT levels manipulated? If I am willing to invest more, the tax return will increase anyway."

Witold Modzelewski, former vice-minister of finance and chief of the Institiute of Tax Studies, disagrees with the idea of a uniform VAT level, however. "A tax should be in some way evaluated by taking its social impact into consideration. Gambling should be taxed more than sausages but unfortunately it is the other way round. As regards VAT on crisps, they should not be given preferential treatment just as alcohol and tobacco are not given preferential treatment. In the case of crisps, the main consumers are children and they are dependent on their parents' financial possibilities. We can expect, therefore, that society will be sympathetic to a rise in VAT on this type of product despite the expectations of the lobbysits of the large corporations and industry groups. It would be good if this matter were to come up for public debate."

A debate we have-- one in which some very different ideas clash. Will the government choose the best solution?

Author: Bronisław Tumiłowicz  Taken from 'Przegłąd' magazine nr.8 (634) 26/02/12

The original Polish article can be read here.

8 comments:

Tendi Agdaniwan said...

terimakasih atas informasinya
obat tradisional asam lambung

Bali Driver said...

Nice post, you have good writing skill
Thank you for sharing this amazing post
Visit my travel blog : Bali Driver and Bali Tours

Dendi Apriadi said...

Nice post, you have good writing skill
Modern Living Room
Living Room Decor 2015
Living Room Table Sets
Living Room Theater
Living Room Furniture

Evee Faranisa said...

indeed article is very useful to everyone, thank you for the information that has been presented successfully yes obat kuat seks pria | Vig Power Capsule | obat kuat modern

Obat Sipilis said...

Do not compare people who love you with your past. Appreciate he is now trying to make you happy.
http://bit.ly/1GorWFZ

Obat Sipilis Di Apotik

Jual Obat Sipilis Ampuh said...

Terimakasih Gan Infonya.Dan Sekalian Ijin Nitip Gan Obat Sipilis,Obat Sipilis Ampuh,Obat Sipilis Manjur,Obat Sipilis Alami,Obat Sipilis Herbal,Obat Sipilis Tradisional,Obat Sipilis Mujarab,Jual Obat Sipilis,Jual Obat Sipilis Ampuh,Gejala Penyakit Sipilis,Ciri Penyakit Sipilis,Penyebab Penyakit Sipilis,Cara Mengobati Sipilis,Cara Menyembuhkan Sipilis,Pengobatan Penyakit Sipilis,Obat Raja Singa,Obat Raja Singa Ampuh.

Booth Pameran said...

Booth Pameran | Stand Pameran I Mini Booth I Booth Portable I Display Booth I Kios I show Case I Counter Booth -Event : Stage I Gate I Backdrop I Pangung dalam bentuk costume - Desain: Exhibition I Interior.

Heru said...

I love it, I think it's a great step in the direction of giving Good Articles the credibility it deserves!


Indonesia Traveling
Desa Beng, Pusat Industri Baju Barong Paling Terkenal
Pantai Kusamba, Pantai Yang Tenang Di Sebelah Tenggara Bali
Pulau Serangan, Pulau Kecil Yang Menawan Di Wilayah Tenggara Pulau Bali
Kebun Raya Purwodadi
Pantai Pandawa, Objek Wisata Yang Indah di Bali
Danau Kelimutu, Danau Unik Tiga Warna di Indonesia
DANAU BUYAN DAN DANAU TAMBLINGAN, TEMPAT YANG COCOK UNTUK SEJENAK LEPAS DARI HIRUK PIKUK KOTA
Pura Rambut Siwi, Candi Dengan Panorama Yang Menawan
Pantai Kedonganan Dan Jimbaran - Tempat yang sempurna untuk Seafood Dinner
Taman Nasional Teluk Cendrawasih
Taman Botani Di Kebun Raya Bogor
Pulau Biawak, Jawa Barat - sebuah tujuan Diving dengan Keunikan Tersendiri
Tiga Tips Investasi Emas yang Perlu Anda Ketahui
Bisakah Kaya Dari Pasar Modal?
Yuk Nabung Saham